2012-13 Detroit Red Wings Pro/No: Kyle Quincey

For the second off-season in a row, we — as well as our good friends at Winging it in Motown — are taking a look at the Red Wings’ upcoming free agents and asking the community for their input. Read all of the important information and then place your vote — should the Wings try to get Kyle Quincey under contract for 2012-13, or was his late-season acquisition a rental?

THE VITALS
Kyle Quincey, Defenseman #27
26 Years Old (August 12, 1985)
6’2″, 207 lbs
4 Full NHL Seasons (257 career regular season games played) – chunks of four seasons in Detroit (31 total games)
Born in Kitchener, Ontario; drafted by the Red Wings in 2003.

STATISTICS
Regular Season (DET and COL combined) – 72 games played, 7 goals, 19 assists, 89 PIM, -1, 21:50 TOI per game.
Playoffs – 5 games played, 0 goals, 2 assist, 6 PIM, -2, 16:28 TOI per game

CONTRACT SITUATION
After a season in Colorado, the Avs re-signed Kyle Quincey to a two-year extension worth an average of $3.125M per season, which was a sizable raise from his previous salary (which the Red Wings signed him to) of $525,000. Chances are slim he’ll get another 600% raise, and some of us even hope that he’s willing to take a haircut to stick around with the Red Wings again. However, it’s a thin crop of free agents and nearly all of them will command Ericsson money, so why not Quincey?

What sets Quincey apart from many of those other defensemen is that he’s a restricted free agent — meaning the Wings will have the right to match any offer he signs, or accept draft pick compensation if they choose to let him walk. His salary is high enough that he’s not eligible for a 10% “qualifying offer” raise.

DEPTH SITUATION
Quincey may have been acquired as a contingency plan in case Brad Stuart departs, which — as we discussed — has seemed likely for quite some time. He was inserted into the lineup and stayed there, though he wasn’t as dependable or as relied upon as Stuart has been since he came from out West. Nevertheless, if Quincey were to be re-signed, he’d remain an everyday player for the Detroit Red Wings. With Nicklas Lidstrom retiring and Stuart likely departing, there are plenty of spots open on the blueline.

CASE FOR QUINCEY
1) The blueline is already in a whole bunch of flux. Nicklas Lidstrom is leaving a void that simply can’t be filled. Brad Stuart is very likely heading West to be with his family. Brian Rafalski departed rather abruptly the season before it. Wouldn’t it be nice if there was some stability, even if I think the team needs to get some fresh blood injected into its veins.
2) Ken Holland said so himself: they never should have let Kyle Quincey leave the first time around (instead opting to keep Derek Meech who is toiling in the Winnipeg Jets’ minor league system). He’s a talented kid, he’s young enough to be just coming into his prime, and he’s a big boy.
3) Strangely, he had better numbers than Brad Stuart last season. 7 goals (compared to 6), 19 assists (instead of 15), and more minutes played (but that’s thanks to playing on the shitty Avs for most of the season).

CASE AGAINST QUINCEY
1) After a spectacular first game with the Wings, he was fairly unimpressive down the stretch and in the playoffs. There was dumb penalty on top of dumb penalty and he needed longer than you’d think someone who “grew up” in the Wings’ system to get re-acquainted.
2) There’s a ton of money in the till during this off-season, so perhaps the Wings would be better served spending this 3ish million on another guy that will play the third pairing.
3) Building on that last bullet point in the “for” header… he also took three times as many penalties as Brad Stuart.

WHAT HE’S SAYING
After admitting that he had a hard time adjusting to a new team in the middle of the season, he spoke as if he fully expends to don the winged wheel on opening night. Per Ted Kulfan of the Detroit News:

It’s just a different role (after a trade). You get a role on any team. You come here, and you have to find your new role. Every team you go on, you’re going to be in a different role.

That’s part of the game. That’s why they pay you.

After a while you kind of see where you fit in. Special teams are where I fit in here the most. You know your role. You come to the rink every day and you know what you have to focus on.

SALARY RANGE
Like I mentioned a little earlier, it’s entirely possible he takes a lower average salary in exchange for some job security or a no-trade clause or whatever. However, he won’t take that much of a bite, so he could come in around $2.75M… or as high as the 4’s. Depending on the role he signs on for and how happy he is to be in Detroit again, expect him in that nieghborhood somewhere.

POTENTIAL REPLACEMENTS

Internal :: We all know that Brendan Smith is ready for primetime and that Jakub Kindl can be relied upon more than he has been in recent years, though they’re different players than Quincey. Aside from that, there’s no one waiting in the wings (as it were).
External :: We’re all (still) hoping for Suter, and then there’s Matt Carle, Bryan Allen, Carlo Colaiacovo, Chris Campoli, Kurt Sauer, and Milan Jurcina on the market.

WHAT DO YOU THINK
Use the form below to give us your take on whether the Wings should try to get Kyle Quincey back at a reasonable rate. Then, sound off in the comments with your thoughts.

11 thoughts on “2012-13 Detroit Red Wings Pro/No: Kyle Quincey”

  1. I voted yes.  Quincey is probably always going to have trouble taking too many penalties. That’s the one constant of his career. But, we kind of do need the power play specialist that he thinks he’s going to be. He’s good on the PP and I think he’s capable on the PK (where the refs are less likely to call you for the little infractions he gets caught up in).  He’s a big body (sometimes) that can eat big minutes and he’s not going to come at a huge salary.

    All of this adds up to the idea that if he’s good, then he’s a damn bargain and if he’s not then he’s at least not an albatross. I want to see him really get accustomed to a role in Detroit before I say that his game (within the context of how badly the Red Wings in general played) late last season is what defines him as a Red Wings blueliner.

  2. I voted yes.  Quincey is probably always going to have trouble taking too many penalties. That’s the one constant of his career. But, we kind of do need the power play specialist that he thinks he’s going to be. He’s good on the PP and I think he’s capable on the PK (where the refs are less likely to call you for the little infractions he gets caught up in).  He’s a big body (sometimes) that can eat big minutes and he’s not going to come at a huge salary.

    All of this adds up to the idea that if he’s good, then he’s a damn bargain and if he’s not then he’s at least not an albatross. I want to see him really get accustomed to a role in Detroit before I say that his game (within the context of how badly the Red Wings in general played) late last season is what defines him as a Red Wings blueliner.

  3. I always looked at Kyle Quincey as a big mistake. He was stellar in Los Angeles, he was pretty good in Colorado, but after he was traded here, I wondered if it was a case of “you always want what you can’t have”. I was never once impressed with him here the way I was when he was with those other teams.

    As a result, I feel his cap hit would be better utilized on a player like Matt Carle. After the (devastating) Lidstrom announcement yesterday, it’s become painfully obvious that this team’s blue line will be a massive project this off-season. Ryan Suter is a must, in my opinion, but even if we signed Suter, I’d want to use Quincey’s hit on Matt Carle.

    If there’s nothing better out there (i.e. we can’t get either) then I guess retain him. But I think there are better players out there who command relatively the same hit.

    Also, I am still sort of optimistic that, after learning the system through a full training camp and the time he spent last season, he’ll put it together. He could still be useful, and I often wondered if it was a case of him trying to do too much.

    So, in summation, I’m unsure.

  4. I always looked at Kyle Quincey as a big mistake. He was stellar in Los Angeles, he was pretty good in Colorado, but after he was traded here, I wondered if it was a case of “you always want what you can’t have”. I was never once impressed with him here the way I was when he was with those other teams.

    As a result, I feel his cap hit would be better utilized on a player like Matt Carle. After the (devastating) Lidstrom announcement yesterday, it’s become painfully obvious that this team’s blue line will be a massive project this off-season. Ryan Suter is a must, in my opinion, but even if we signed Suter, I’d want to use Quincey’s hit on Matt Carle.

    If there’s nothing better out there (i.e. we can’t get either) then I guess retain him. But I think there are better players out there who command relatively the same hit.

    Also, I am still sort of optimistic that, after learning the system through a full training camp and the time he spent last season, he’ll put it together. He could still be useful, and I often wondered if it was a case of him trying to do too much.

    So, in summation, I’m unsure.

  5.  No on Quincey.  He’s a terrible fit for the organization.  His penalties just killed us.  Dump him.  We’re losing two huge talents in Lidstrom and Stuart, I say use the money to fill those spots with big talents.  Both Suter and Jackman are UFA, and there’s no reason that with $26 million in cap space (the cap is projected to rise to $70 million) we can’t get both.

  6. I think they have to re-sign him with the many holes they have on the blue line, but I wouldn’t want to pay any more than $3 million. There’s no guarantee that Suter will be signed, and I’m not a huge Kindl fan – I’ve seen way to many bone-headed mistakes from him. A full off-season and preseason with the team should be enough for him to find his role.

  7. I saw flashes of brilliance from Quincey in terms of breaking up plays with his stick, and for a young defenseman, it’s hard to give that up. He’s only 26, and I think about the difference between Ericsson two years ago at 26 and this past year when he’s becoming competent, and even missed when he’s injured. I don’t know what to pay him, but I’m comfortable with him replacing Stuart, particularly with the train wreck he was in the playoffs.

  8. I said no. I was just so fed up with the dumb Kyle Quincey penalties and a whole lot of meh the rest of the time. I never felt myself go “Yay Kyle Quincey!” outside of the one goal he scored for us. I’d rather let someone else snag him and get some draft picks for our trouble and bring in some outside talent. And honestly, I’d like to see Brendan Smith AND Jakub Kindl come up. Kronwall, White, Ericsson, Kindl and Smith with Ryan Suter. Or Kronwall, White, Ericsson, and Smith with Ryan Suter and another big FA signing. 

  9. Other than a few dump penalties… Quincey is a very solid D-man, he is great with his stick to break up plays. He has a great first pass too. Oh and pretty sure he saved 3 or 4 goals from going in in the playoffs.. He will be very good next year. I would sign him in a second! Rather have him than brad Stuart who made a sh@t load of mistakes in the playoffs.

  10. i said yes, because he about ready to hit his prime and he has shown good playm in the past. He’ll never be a lidstrom type but he could be a stuart replacement? So he give him a shot!

  11. I vote “yes”.  The penalties will hopefully decrease this year and we need a steady presence on special teams and I really think he can be that.

Comments are closed.