Comments on: Pro/No :: Nicklas Lidstrom https://tpl.detroit.hockey/2011/06/16/prono-nicklas-lidstrom/ Archived version of TPL - Hosted by DetroitHockey.Net Thu, 16 Jun 2011 21:16:00 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.5.3 By: Kjell Mickelson https://tpl.detroit.hockey/2011/06/16/prono-nicklas-lidstrom/#comment-4367 Thu, 16 Jun 2011 21:16:00 +0000 https://tplarchive.detroithockey.net/?p=4595#comment-4367 Did it hurt writing down reasons to NOT sign Lidstrom? I think my fingers would cry if I tried to.

]]>
By: Michael Petrella https://tpl.detroit.hockey/2011/06/16/prono-nicklas-lidstrom/#comment-4366 Thu, 16 Jun 2011 19:41:00 +0000 https://tplarchive.detroithockey.net/?p=4595#comment-4366 In reply to mike.

I doubt Rypien is a target, because anyone that can’t stick in a Canucks lineup likely won’t be able to stick in a Wings lineup. No disrespect to the Cancuks, obviously, because they’re a hell of a squad. That’s just not the kind of guy the Red Wings would put faith in to be an everyday player in Detroit.

I think that ONE of the Canucks defensemen will have to make it to the market — Bieksa, Salo, and Ehrhoff are all due a bit of a raise and the Canucks will be in a sticky situation to get them under contract.

]]>
By: Michael Petrella https://tpl.detroit.hockey/2011/06/16/prono-nicklas-lidstrom/#comment-4365 Thu, 16 Jun 2011 19:38:00 +0000 https://tplarchive.detroithockey.net/?p=4595#comment-4365 In reply to Lauren Horne.

In a couple weeks, Winging it in Motown and The Production Line will have summary posts up to dissect all of the numbers. We decided we’d like to wait until all of the numbers were in, just in case seeing Ruslan Salei’s % might skew the numbers for, say, Jonathan Ericsson. 

Worry not, we’ve kept meticulous track of the thousands upon thousands of votes over the weeks! 

]]>
By: Lauren Horne https://tpl.detroit.hockey/2011/06/16/prono-nicklas-lidstrom/#comment-4364 Thu, 16 Jun 2011 18:37:00 +0000 https://tplarchive.detroithockey.net/?p=4595#comment-4364 In reply to Michael Petrella.

Where do I see the results of all of the voting for these Pro/No posts?

]]>
By: Crater from SoCal https://tpl.detroit.hockey/2011/06/16/prono-nicklas-lidstrom/#comment-4363 Thu, 16 Jun 2011 18:28:00 +0000 https://tplarchive.detroithockey.net/?p=4595#comment-4363 if he wins the Norris i say give him 8 mil just for fun. He is TPH, any amount is reasonable.

]]>
By: Josh https://tpl.detroit.hockey/2011/06/16/prono-nicklas-lidstrom/#comment-4361 Thu, 16 Jun 2011 18:21:00 +0000 https://tplarchive.detroithockey.net/?p=4595#comment-4361 In reply to Michael Petrella.

Yeah, I neglected to throw age in when figuring out other potential top tier d-man substitutes.

And yes, I agree 100% on Wisniewski.  He’s from Canton and played for Plymouth, not to mention he’s a talented d-man with loads of potential still in the bag.  He and Smith could be a dangerous duo in a few years (Smith, sadly, is still a few years from truly being ready.)  I’ve been pushing full steam ahead for Wisniewski and Ian White ever since I realized that Shea Weber was not even a remote possibility for us.  Unfortunately, Ian White may be out our reach now too.  As I mentioned this morning on WiiM, Niclas Wallin bolted for Finland, likely meaning the Sharks will press hard to resign White.

]]>
By: Josh https://tpl.detroit.hockey/2011/06/16/prono-nicklas-lidstrom/#comment-4362 Thu, 16 Jun 2011 18:21:00 +0000 https://tplarchive.detroithockey.net/?p=4595#comment-4362 In reply to Michael Petrella.

Yeah, I neglected to throw age in when figuring out other potential top tier d-man substitutes.

And yes, I agree 100% on Wisniewski.  He’s from Canton and played for Plymouth, not to mention he’s a talented d-man with loads of potential still in the bag.  He and Smith could be a dangerous duo in a few years (Smith, sadly, is still a few years from truly being ready.)  I’ve been pushing full steam ahead for Wisniewski and Ian White ever since I realized that Shea Weber was not even a remote possibility for us.  Unfortunately, Ian White may be out our reach now too.  As I mentioned this morning on WiiM, Niclas Wallin bolted for Finland, likely meaning the Sharks will press hard to resign White.

]]>
By: mike https://tpl.detroit.hockey/2011/06/16/prono-nicklas-lidstrom/#comment-4359 Thu, 16 Jun 2011 18:09:00 +0000 https://tplarchive.detroithockey.net/?p=4595#comment-4359 How about Kevin Bieksa? He is going to fetch about the same amount 6mil or so on the free agent market…do the wings try to talk to him? Or a guy i think would be great to have or at least talk to is Rick Rypien…granted he’s been out for the last half of the season and now plays for the Manitoba Moose…

]]>
By: mike https://tpl.detroit.hockey/2011/06/16/prono-nicklas-lidstrom/#comment-4360 Thu, 16 Jun 2011 18:09:00 +0000 https://tplarchive.detroithockey.net/?p=4595#comment-4360 How about Kevin Bieksa? He is going to fetch about the same amount 6mil or so on the free agent market…do the wings try to talk to him? Or a guy i think would be great to have or at least talk to is Rick Rypien…granted he’s been out for the last half of the season and now plays for the Manitoba Moose…

]]>
By: Michael Petrella https://tpl.detroit.hockey/2011/06/16/prono-nicklas-lidstrom/#comment-4357 Thu, 16 Jun 2011 18:05:00 +0000 https://tplarchive.detroithockey.net/?p=4595#comment-4357 In reply to Eric.

Essentially. Although, you’ll be surprised to see some of the voting numbers so far… maybe this will be another one. 
Somehow I doubt it. HA

]]>